K-Beauty Battle Royale: Global Viral Sensations vs. Korean Holy Grails!

Unmasking the True Champions of Korean Skincare

CYoungCYoungJan 2025
K-Beauty Battle Royale: Global Viral Sensations vs. Korean Holy Grails!

Watch the full video

Mentioned Products

Hey everyone, CYOUNG here! Back in my new place, ready to delve into the captivating world of K-beauty. Today, we're pitting the biggest global K-beauty hits against the undisputed favorites reigning supreme here in Korea. You guys absolutely loved the previous comparison videos, so I'm thrilled to bring you another installment. We'll be looking at products you're likely already using or have tried in the past, so get ready to share your thoughts in the comments! Let's jump right in!

Round 1: Essence - Snail Slime vs. Bean Power

COSRX Snail Mucin 96% Power Face Serum

This essence has reached global stardom, and for good reason. The COSRX Snail Mucin 96% Power Face Serum boasts a unique, viscous texture that delivers an instant cooling sensation upon application. However, that refreshing feeling is fleeting. It evaporates remarkably quickly, requiring frequent reapplication. While this might be suitable for younger, teenage skin with minimal moisturizing needs, those of us with drier, more mature skin (especially those past our late 20s) will find it lacking. It's a fun, sensorial experience, but the hydration simply doesn't last. Sorry, COSRX, but this one isn't a holy grail for everyone.

Snail Rescue Blemish Busting Toner
Snail Rescue Blemish Busting Toner

Hydrating, for Face, Self Care, Glow Skin under Makeup

tl;dr

A fun, sensorial experience, but the hydration doesn't last long.

Pros
  • Instant cooling sensation, suitable for teenage skin.
Cons
  • Requires frequent reapplication, not suitable for mature skin.

Mixsoon Bean Essence

Often touted as a vegan alternative to snail mucin due to its similar consistency, the Mixsoon Bean Essence offers more than just hydration. While it can be used as a regular serum, its true power lies in its unique exfoliating properties. Here's the secret: after cleansing, pat your face to remove excess water, leaving it slightly damp. Pump the essence onto your damp skin and begin massaging. Pump two more times, aiming for at least five pumps total. This generous amount allows for a smooth, gliding massage without tugging at the skin. Think of it as a meditative skincare ritual. After five to seven minutes of gentle massage, you might notice tiny grains forming on your fingers. This is the essence working its magic, gently lifting away dead skin cells and impurities. Rinse with water, and you're done! Even if you don't see visible grains, the essence is still effectively refining your skin texture and boosting hydration. I highly recommend incorporating this exfoliating massage into your routine once a week for noticeably smoother, more radiant skin.

Essence Jumbo - 12 Types
Essence Jumbo - 12 Types

Natural Fermented Soybean Serum for Hydration and Nourishing Skin

tl;dr

Vegan alternative to snail mucin with exfoliating properties.

Pros
  • Exfoliates and hydrates, vegan-friendly.
Cons
  • Requires a specific application method for best results.

Round 2: Milky Toners - Rice vs. Cream

I'm From Rice Toner

The I'm From Rice Toner has gained international acclaim for its milky, yet lightweight texture. This makes it a versatile option for various skin types, including oily and combination skin. Milky toners, a blend of toner and cream, offer superior hydration compared to watery toners. While they are particularly beneficial for dry and mature skin, the I'm From Rice Toner's lighter consistency makes it a comfortable choice even for those prone to excess oil. It provides a crucial first layer of hydration, prepping the skin for subsequent skincare steps.

I'm From Rice Toner
I'm From Rice Toner

Korean Rice skincare for glowing, smooth, dry, combination skin

tl;dr

Lightweight milky toner suitable for multiple skin types.

Pros
  • Versatile, provides superior hydration.
Cons
  • None noted.

Laneige Cream Skin Refiner

A Korean staple, the Laneige Cream Skin Refiner has undergone a reformulation, resulting in a slightly lighter texture. It delivers excellent hydration, and those with dry or mature skin can layer it multiple times for enhanced moisturizing benefits. While both toners are effective, the I'm From Rice Toner edges out the Laneige Cream Skin Refiner due to its lighter feel and more accessible price point.

Round 3: Moisturizers - Barrier Repair Showdown

Dr. Jart+ Ceramidin Cream

Marketed as a skin barrier repair cream, the Dr. Jart+ Ceramidin Cream functions more like a daily moisturizer enriched with niacinamide and panthenol. While suitable for younger skin types and those dealing with post-acne concerns, it might not provide sufficient moisture for dry, mature, or severely damaged skin. Some users have also reported pilling, particularly if applied to skin prone to breakouts.

La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Baume B5

A true skin-saving hero, the La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Baume B5 reigns supreme in Korea. This ointment-like balm is a constant bestseller, recommended by dermatologists and consistently topping Olive Young charts. Its thick, protective formula requires warming between the fingers before application to avoid a white cast. Ideal for severely dry, sensitive, and even eczema-prone skin, the Cicaplast Baume B5 provides intense relief and promotes healing. While the Dr. Jart+ Ceramidin Cream is a decent daily moisturizer, the La Roche-Posay Cicaplast Baume B5 is the ultimate barrier repair champion for those in need of serious skin rescue.

Round 4: Wash-Off Masks - Rice vs. Honey

Beauty of Joseon Rice Mask

The Beauty of Joseon Rice Mask, a newer iteration of their red bean and rice mask, boasts a smoother, more refined formula. It's incredibly easy to apply and leaves skin feeling refreshed and revitalized after rinsing. With a pleasant, subtle scent and an affordable price tag, it's no wonder this mask consistently ranks high on Olive Young bestseller lists, especially during the colder months.

BEAUTY OF JOSEON - Ground Rice and Honey Glow Mask - 150ml
BEAUTY OF JOSEON - Ground Rice and Honey Glow Mask - 150ml

Ground Rice and Honey Glow Mask - 150ml

tl;dr

Affordable mask that refreshes and revitalizes skin.

Pros
  • Easy application, subtle scent.
Cons
  • None noted.

I'm From Honey Mask

A true cult favorite, the I'm From Honey Mask is my personal gateway into the I'm From brand. Its intensely rich, honey-infused formula delivers unparalleled hydration. Be mindful of the strong honey scent, which might be overwhelming for some. Apply a generous layer and leave it on for anywhere between 10 minutes to an hour (I like to apply it before showering and rinse it off in the shower). The honey mask provides a level of deep hydration that surpasses sheet masks, leaving skin incredibly plump and bouncy. Due to its sticky consistency, a thorough rinse and a quick swipe with a toner pad are recommended to remove any residue.

Honey Mask
Honey Mask

Intensely rich, honey-infused formula

tl;dr

Deeply hydrating mask with a strong honey scent.

Pros
  • Intense hydration, plumps skin.
Cons
  • Strong honey scent.

Round 5: Sunscreens - Lightweight vs. Tone-Up

Skin1004 Madagascar Centella Air Fit Suncream

The Skin1004 Madagascar Centella Air Fit Suncream has garnered a devoted following for its weightless feel and seamless application. It layers beautifully under makeup and is suitable for all skin types, with minimal white cast even on deeper complexions.

SKIN1004 - Madagascar Centella Hyalu-Cica Water-Fit Sun Serum SPF50 PA++++ - 50ml
SKIN1004 - Madagascar Centella Hyalu-Cica Water-Fit Sun Serum SPF50 PA++++ - 50ml

SPF50 PA++++ - 50ml

tl;dr

Weightless sunscreen with minimal white cast.

Pros
  • Lightweight, suitable for all skin types.
Cons
  • None noted.

d'Alba Piedmont Waterfull Tone-Up Sun Cream

A bestseller in Korea, the d'Alba Piedmont Waterfull Tone-Up Sun Cream offers a tinted moisturizer effect, often used as a foundation alternative. Its pinkish-beige hue provides a subtle tone-up effect. This hybrid sunscreen, containing both mineral and chemical filters, leans towards the oilier side, making it ideal for dry and mature skin. Oily or combination skin types might find it too heavy. If you find it too oily, try applying it with a makeup sponge for better control. Due to its pinkish tint, it's not recommended for those with rosacea or darker complexions, as it can leave a white cast.

d'alba Piedmont Waterfull Tone-Up & Essence &Mild Sunscreen TRIO: BROAD SPECTRUM SPF 50+ Glowy, Lightweight Sunscreen, Safe for all Skin Types, Korean Skin Care
d'alba Piedmont Waterfull Tone-Up & Essence &Mild Sunscreen TRIO: BROAD SPECTRUM SPF 50+ Glowy, Lightweight Sunscreen, Safe for all Skin Types, Korean Skin Care

BROAD SPECTRUM SPF 50+ Glowy, Lightweight Sunscreen

tl;dr

Tinted sunscreen with a tone-up effect.

Pros
  • Glowy finish, suitable for dry skin.
Cons
  • May leave a white cast on darker complexions.

Round 6: Powders - Cushion Compact vs. Loose Powder

Laneige Neo Cushion Matte Finish Powder

While the Laneige Neo Cushion Matte Finish Powder boasts adorable cushion compact packaging, its performance falls short. The powder is difficult to control, dispersing excessively with each tap. The compact design also makes it challenging to gauge the remaining product.

Vanilla Co. Prime Primer Finish Powder

While popular in Korea, the Vanilla Co. Prime Primer Finish Powder's strong scent is a major drawback. Both powders also tend to feel overly drying on the skin. Neither of these powders makes the cut for me. My personal recommendation remains the Make Up For Ever Ultra HD Microfinishing Loose Powder, a finely milled, blurring powder that sets makeup flawlessly without drying out the skin.

Round 7: Multi-Products - Lip & Cheek Power

Fwee Lip & Cheek Blurry Pudding Pot

The Fwee Lip & Cheek Blurry Pudding Pot offers a fun, pudding-like texture and an impressive range of 30 shades, catering to various skin tones. Its dual functionality as both a lip and cheek product makes it a convenient option, especially for beginners.

Lip&Cheek Blurry Pudding Pot - 30 Colors
Lip&Cheek Blurry Pudding Pot - 30 Colors

Multi-purpose lip and cheek product

tl;dr

Fun texture with dual functionality for lips and cheeks.

Pros
  • Wide shade range, convenient for beginners.
Cons
  • None noted.

Too Cool For School Art Class By Rodin Shading Master Multi-Pencil

The Too Cool For School Art Class By Rodin Shading Master Multi-Pencil offers incredible versatility. While commonly used for creating aegyosal (the subtle puff of fat under the eyes), its uses extend far beyond. The pencil is available in 14 shades, suitable for eyeshadow, highlighting, and even lip lining. The lightest shade makes for a precise, easy-to-apply highlighter, while the pink and peachy shades double as lip liners.

Round 8: Lip Tints - Glowy Goodness

Peripera Ink the Velvet Lip Tint

The Peripera Ink the Velvet Lip Tint has achieved global recognition for its long-lasting, moisturizing formula and vibrant color payoff. Shades like #03 Warm Bath and #05 Cool Bath are particularly popular. The formula is comfortable even on dry lips and applies effortlessly, even without a mirror.

Rom&nd Juicy Lasting Tint

The Rom&nd Juicy Lasting Tint, specifically the shade Bear Grape, reigns supreme in Korea. This mauve-pink hue offers a natural, "my lips but better" look. However, it might not be the best choice for those with darker lips or lip lines, as it can fade quickly.

Olive Young Adventure!

Olive Young, Korea's leading beauty retailer, recently opened its largest store ever! Spanning an entire floor, it's a K-beauty paradise. The store showcases the best-selling products of 2024 in creative displays, offers exclusive merchandise like eco-bags, and even features brands typically found in department stores, like HERA. They also champion sustainability with refillable product options. If you're ever in Seoul, this is a must-visit destination.

That's all for today! I hope this K-beauty showdown helped you navigate the vast world of Korean skincare. Stay healthy, and I'll see you in the next video! (Just kidding – next blog post!)